The Pros and Cons of Dethatching Lawn: Everything You Need to Know

Have you been considering dethatching your lawn? If so, you’re likely wondering if it’s worth the time and money. In this blog post, we’ll break down the pros and cons of dethatching lawn so that you can make an informed decision. Keep reading to learn more!

In a Hurry? Here is a quick breakdown of the pros and cons of dethatching lawn. We go into greater detail below, but this is the nitty-gritty.

Pros	Cons
Opens up access to the soil	Removes natural mulch
Stimulates deeper roots	Stresses your lawn
Fewer insects	May damage grass
Reduces disease	Can cause increased soil temperature
Promotes better drainage	Can stimulate weeds growth.
Better results in overseeding	Removes nature’s protection against wear and tear
Neater lawn

As you can see, there are almost as many arguments against dethatching as there are for it. So, what is a gardener to do? To dethatch or not to dethatch? Well, that is the question. Experts agree that a thin layer of thatch will benefit your lawn. A general rule of thumb is that thatch should not be greater than 1/3 inch in cool-season grasses and 1/2 inch in warm-season grasses.

Under 1/2 inch? No need to dethatch.
Over 1/2 inch? It is time to think about dethatching.

What Is Thatch?

Before we discuss the pros and cons of dethatching, we should explain what thatch is. Thatch is a layer of organic matter that accumulates between the grass and the soil. It can be composed of dead grass blades, stems, roots, and other plant debris. Lawn thatch develops when the organic matter is produced faster than it decomposes.

This post contains affiliate links. This means we earn a commission from sales made via product links in this post. For more information, click here.

What is Dethatching?

Dethatching is the process of intentionally removing the thatch from a lawn. It involves cutting through the thatch and then removing it. You can use a special dethatching rake that has sharp blade-like tines. This process is hard work and is best reserved for small lawns. A more efficient way is to use an electric dethatcher or power rake. This machine cuts through the thatch and pulls it up.

Sun Joe Electric Lawn Dethatcher & Scarifier

Check On Amazon

The Pros And Cons of Dethatching Lawn

The Pros

Dethatching your lawn may seem like a daunting task, but the benefits are worth it! You’ll be rewarded with a healthy, lush green carpet that’s less prone to disease and pests. Here are just a few of the reasons why you should dethatch your lawn this year.

It opens up access to the soil so water, nutrients, and oxygen can penetrate and reach the roots of the grass. This leads to deeper root growth and a happier lawn.
It stimulates the grass to grow deep roots. If the thatch layer is too thick, the grassroots can grow in the thatch instead of penetrating the soil. These shallow roots make your grass weaker and unable to cope with drought conditions and other stresses.
Results in less insect damage. Dense thatch can provide a friendly habitat for undesirable insects that damage the grass.
Reduces fungal disease as most spores thrive in thatch. Thatch holds the moisture near the soil’s surface, restricts airflow, and weakens the grass. This creates ideal conditions in which fungal disease thrives.
Dethatching allows you to remove all the dead grass, debris, and other accumulated organic matter. Your lawn will look neater as a result.
Getting rid of that thatch layer allows new grass seeds to reach the soil and germinate. Grass seedlings also need sunlight and moisture to grow properly. Clearing the thatch opens everything up, so the new seedlings can thrive.
Thatch builds up a barrier between the grass blades and soil. This means the water will not soak into the ground during heavy rain. You may find yourself with mud puddles and excessive runoff. Removing the barrier promotes better drainage.

The Cons

Now that you’ve looked at the pros of dethatching your lawn, you may be eager to get going on your grass. But what if I told you that dethatching your lawn may not be such a good idea in certain circumstances? It could even do more harm than good. Keep reading to find out some of the cons of dethatching your lawn.

Removes the natural mulch layer; a thin layer (less than 1/2 inch) of thatch acts as a natural mulch for the grass. This helps to prevent excessive evaporation and keeps the moisture in the soil. Removing it takes away all those benefits.
Can cause increased soil temperature and fluctuations. The thin blanket of thatch also regulates the temperature of the soil as it shades it from the sun. This prevents the grass from the stress of extreme temperature fluctuation. Taking this protective insulation away can be particularly harmful in drought conditions.
Stresses your lawn. Dethatching is a very aggressive process, and it will cause short-term stress to your lawn.
It may damage the grass; dethatching inevitably tears, rips, and pulls out turf. This can cause damage to the grass and thin your lawn. If you must deal with a thick layer of thatch (two inches or more), you may find it impossible to remove without severe thinning.
It can provide an opportunity for weeds to grow. As we have seen, thatch forms a layer of insulation that can be helpful. This layer also acts as a barrier to prevent weed seeds from germinating. If the seed cannot touch the soil surface, it will struggle to germinate. The initial roots will grow in the thatch if weeds get started, making them easy to pull.
Removes nature’s protection against wear and tear; that protective blanket we talked about earlier? Well, it also protects your grass against wear and tear, such as foot traffic.

Finding this post helpful? See all our lawn care articles.

How Do I Know If My Lawn Needs Dethatching?

Horticulturists recommend dethatching when the thatch reaches 1/3 inch in cool-season grasses and 1/2 inch in warm-season grasses.

Here are some of the signs that indicate your lawn needs dethatching.

Your grass looks dry or has dry spots.
Your grass feels “spongy” when you walk on it. You may even notice footprints after you walk over it.
You are dealing with increased disease and more insect problems.
The grass shows wilting or stress in extreme cold or heat.

The best way to check your thatch is to dig down and take a look. With a trowel or other tool, dig out several plugs of turf. You want to dig down far enough to remove the turf, thatch, and some of the underlying soil. Then you can measure the thatch from the soil to the top of the layer.

You can do the finger test if you don’t want to dig plugs out of your lawn. It is not as accurate but will give you a decent enough measurement. Gently push a finger through the thatch layer until it hits the soil. Make a mark on your finger where it hits the top of the thatch layer. Pull your finger out and measure from your fingertip to the mark you made.

Not sure if you should dethatch or aerate? Read our post outlining the difference between the two.

What Month Should You Dethatch Your Lawn?

It depends on what kind of grass you have on your lawn.

If you have a warm-season lawn, you need to dethatch during February and March, just before green-up.
Homeowners with cool-season lawns should wait until late September through to mid-October.

What Should I Do After I Dethatch My Lawn?

There is no doubt about it thatch removal is hard on the grass. So, you will want to do some things to help your lawn recover.

First, rake up all the removed thatch and dispose of it. The best way to do this is to compost it or send it to your local composting site.

Aerate your lawn using a spike aerator or core aerator to help loosen compacted soils. Topdressing may be needed, especially if your grass seems thin or has bare patches. Water and fertilize as needed. Watch out for weeds, as those bare patches are the ideal spot for them to take hold. You may need to use a selective weed killer or pull them before they get established. With a bit of care, your lawn should bounce back nicely.

How Often Should You Dethatch Your Yard?

You only need to dethatch your yard when the thatch layer gets thick enough to warrant it. As we have mentioned, that is 1/3 inch in cool-season grasses and 1/2 inch in warm-season grasses. Thatch removal is hard work and does stress the grass, so we only want to do it when necessary.

Can You Prevent Excessive Thatch Buildup?

The best way to avoid dethatching altogether is to prevent the buildup of excess thatch in the first place.

Encourage nature’s helper, also known as earthworms. They help to aerate the soil, promoting the breakdown of organic material. They also pull down the organic material into the soil.
Do not over-fertilize, which will encourage excessive growth, leading to thatch buildup. High levels of nitrogen are particularly problematic. The best way to avoid this is to take regular soil tests and fertilize according to the results. Kits for testing the soil are readily available.
Watch the acidity of the earth under your grass. According to the University of Kentucky Extension Service. Microorganisms that break down the thatch work best in a neutral pH range, between 6.0 and 8.0.
Use grasses that are not prone to thatch, such as tall fescue and perennial ryegrass. Some grasses tend to produce more thatch, so you may want to avoid them if you can. Species include Kentucky Bluegrass, zoysia, Bermuda, and Creeping Bentgrass.

Check Out Some of Our Other Lawn Maintenance Posts

Final Thoughts On The Pros and Cons of Dethatching Lawn

Dethatching is the process of removing thatch from the lawn. In this post, we discussed the pros and cons of dethatching lawn. We hope that it helps you make an informed decision about whether or not to dethatch your lawn. To summarize, dethatching is hard on the grass. Consequently, it would be best if you only dethatched when the layer of thatch becomes too thick. Your grass will thank you!